Sunday 9 November 2008

Unfashionable Megson still not everyone's cup of tea

Sitting comfortably in mid-table, after two wins and clean sheets in a row, you'd think Bolton fans would be fairly content with their team's form, and their manager Gary Megson.

After all, Megson kept Bolton up in remarkable circumstances last year, after Sammy Lee's disastarious tenure in charge. And there was even a decent UEFA Cup run to boot, with memorable results against the likes of Bayern Munich and Red Star Belgrade something to savour.

Yet there are still rumblings of discontent from the Wanderers faithful. The football is too negative, apparantly, with Bolton more concerned about keeping a clean sheet than actually going and scoring at the other end.

But there lies the problem. Because football, first and foremost, is a results business. There's just too much money involved for teams to go out and attack these days. The risk is simply too much, with the money in the Premiership so vital, especially for teams like Bolton. Relegation would be disastarous.

Taking a step back to last season, and after the departure of Sam Allardyce, Bolton decided to change things. Sammy Lee attempted to get Wanderers playing a more expansive brand of football after the direct style of Allardyce, but ultimately failed, with only five points from their opening ten games a poor return. The experiment could so easily have cost Bolton their Premiership status.
So Gartside went back to basics, and went back to what he knew. Lee was given the boot, and to the dismay of many, Megson was appointed. Fans at the Reebok Stadium were outraged, so much so that only 1.7 per cent of fans were in favour of his appointment, according to a website poll.

Talk about starting on the wrong foot.

Then again, this is nothing new for Megson. He's never been a popular manager, with his pragmatic style of play never endearing him to fans, who prefer to see attractive, attacking football. And who doesnt? But pretty football doesnt get you out of a relegation battle. It's about rolling your sleeves up, working hard, and getting the basics right.

So Megson got to work, and got Bolton doing the basics properly again. Of course, it took time, but slowly but surely, the Trotters began to get results. They were hard working, organised, defensively sound, and strong from set-pieces. The old Bolton Wanderers were back, doing what they did best, playing to their strengths, and doing what they needed to do to stay up.

What's more, the loss of influential striker Nicolas Anelka in January was seen to be the last straw by many, with the goals supply surely drying up. He was seen as the only bit of quality in an otherwise mediocre side. Without Anelka, there were no goals, and seemingly no hope.

But Megson didn't panic, and strenghened elsewhere in the squad. Matt Taylor, Gary Cahill, and Gretar Steinsson were all trafted in, amongst others. Once again, they weren't signings to get the fans pulses racing, but they were hard working players who would give their all for the cause. And the new signings certainly had the desired effect, as the likes of Cahill and Taylor all played their part in keeping Bolton in the Premiership.

And so Bolton did stay up, in what was quite frankly a remarkable achievement. At one stage, Bolton looked dead and buried, and some journalists had wrote them off completely, condemning the team to relegation. But in the end, we were all proved wrong, as Bolton pulled off what was in my eyes one of the greatest turnarounds in recent history.

There was even the added bonus of a profitable run in the UEFA Cup, though the competition eventually proved to be too much of a distraction, as Megson put the club's domestic campaign first. Once again, Megson was criticised for not giving the competition enough respect, but in the end his decision proved to be vindicated.

Now moving onto this season, and it's been more of the same from Bolton and Megson, and the fans don't like it. Sure, it's been an inconsistent start, and results havent always been good. And the style of play hasn't changed.

But given the way Megson turned things round last season, you'd think Bolton fans would be more patient towards the man who kept them up against the odds last season.

The abuse that Megson suffered at the hands of his own fans away at Tottenham was nothing short of ridiculous, and in my opinion completely undeserved.

Then again, football fans have notoriously short memories, don't they? Megson out? Be careful what you wish for..

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Your defence of Megson is flawed for several reasons. Firstly, you say we had a good Uefa Cup run last season. It could have been even better had Megson not surrendered our place in the competition by fielding a reserve team in Lisbon.

Secondly, the suggestion that Megson's style of play is the same as Sam Allardyce's is over simplistic. Under Allardyce there was always room in the team for creativity. We also played with much more spirit in the Allardyce years.

You say football is a results business. Any analysis of Megson's stats show that on the whole he doesn't deliver results.

If you weren't at the Tottenham game - or any others we've played this season then you cannot possibly say the abuse he received was ridiculous. It was the final straw for many who pay good money to watch Bolton week in week out and have every right to voice their disapproval.

Here's just a couple of reasons why...

http://mannyroad.wordpress.com/2008/10/30/bolton-wanderers-no-plan-b/

http://mannyroad.wordpress.com/2008/10/27/painful-home-truths-for-gary-megson/

Finally, whether Megson is fashionable or not is irrelevant. Bolton Wanderers are not and never have been fashionable, and neither was Sam ALlardyce... so why would we care if Megson is?

Nobes said...

The point the author makes is that a sustained UEFA Cup run could have been to the detriment of your Premier League form.

He was appointed to keep you in the Premier League - not to give you a good UEFA Cup run. The fact you had a moderately successful European campaign was a bonus.

Megson delivered the results to keep you safe - therefore he does deliver results. That was his brief when he took the job and he accomplished the task.

Whether it was done with style or not is irrelevant. He achieved the target he was hired to.

Nick Howson said...

Firstly Sammy Lee has almost the same squad as he did when Allardyce left, he in-fact strengthened the squad bringing in Gavin McCann and Christian Willhelmson
I think we all agree that Lee tried to play football that both Bolton and he couldn't deal with getting rid of him saved the club for sure
however he did only leave after ten games, 5 points I think u say they had
now if I'm correct from the remaining 28 games u can win 87 points
the same bolton side won 56 from last season playing in a very similar style to Megson's, and finished seventh the highest ever position achieved by a bolton side in the premiership. yes after loosing a manager like allardyce who wanted to further his career,(just like redknapp and go to a bigger club) they were going to struggle for a bit, but for an experienced manager who has managed West Brom in the same league before it shouldn't have been to much trouble. Even with 28 games left they finished 16th one point off the relegation zone
now he did turn round the sides fortunes obviously, but only just and not the magnitude that he should have, with the squad at his disposal, a side who qualified for europe he should be aiming for mid-table at least. for me he has never been a premiership manager, and doing the bare minimum like he did at bolton is typical of him

in this new season, his first full in charge mind you he has spent big-wel in comparison to allardyce did. he spent 13.5 million on two players and bought three others in on loan
now I'm not having a go at his progress this season, he done ok 11th is where he should have finished last season.
at the end of the day 31 points from 28 games from a team who reached the uefa cup that is simply not getting the most out of the team
he underachieved massively with them, i can understand manager saving clubs with 15-20 games to go, not with over two thirds of it to go he was lucky to keep them up and won't be allowed a similar finish this season
the fans should be happy that they stayed up to begin with and take into account that they have been overachieving for years, one year of slipping can be accepted since there promotion.
another season of the same won't be accepted, expecially with the investment he's made